Frequent themes in the reviews include praise for attentive and personable servers, efficient handling of busy periods, and the consistently enjoyable main courses, particularly the crab and appetizers. Customers appreciate the restaurant's historic reputation and special touches, such as bibs for crab dishes and an engaging environment. Several reviewers remark that prices are high, suggesting the visit is best reserved for special occasions or for those seeking iconic Miami dining experiences.
Overall, Joe's Stone Crab has built a reputation in Miami for dependable seafood, positive service experiences, and memorable group visits. Despite minor critiques, recurring positive references to staff attitude, food quality, and a unique local atmosphere support Joe's status as a prominent seafood restaurant in the area.