Frequent themes across multiple reviews include exceptional personal service, with staff often going above and beyond to help customers find the right fit or style, and even resolving product issues promptly. The store’s selection, particularly for children’s shoes, is noted as extensive given its size, with occasional mentions of competitive sales and online ordering with in-store collection. A few parents appreciate the shop’s attention to milestones, such as commemorating a child's first pair of shoes.
Overall, Humphries is regarded as a reliable and welcoming shoe shop in Redditch. Its reputation is built on strong staff engagement and customer service, backed by long-term loyalty from local families and frequent repeat visits. While minor operational and policy drawbacks exist, the company is generally appreciated for its flexibility, product variety, and attentive support, making it a staple for shoe shopping in the region.