Tony'S Di Napoli Reviews
Rated 4.6 based on 6325 Reviews
Italian Restaurants in New York
147 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, United States
Published on
January 30, 2024
Last updated
July 10, 2025
Tony's Di Napoli has cultivated a positive reputation through an inviting atmosphere and hearty meals, leading to an overall commendable customer experience. Reviewers consistently describe the ambiance as 'upbeat', 'fun', and 'vibrant,' which contributes significantly to the dining experience. In particular, the staff's friendliness and engagement, including instances of singing waiters, enhance the restaurant's charm. The food quality receives praise, with the ‘deliciousness’ of traditional southern Italian dishes being a recurring theme. Portion sizes are frequently highlighted as generous, implying value for money, although the family-style service does lead to comments about the impracticality of table sizes for smaller parties. Despite the busyness and resultant noise levels, the efficient service seems to mitigate any serious inconvenience, and the ability to be seated without reservations at the bar is an appreciated flexibility.
Tony's Di Napoli offers a vibrant atmosphere and family-style servings, which can be enjoyed by small parties. However, some customers have noted that the tables for two might feel cramped due to the large portion sizes. Making a reservation is recommended for a better seating arrangement.
While the restaurant specializes in traditional southern Italian cuisine, there are limited vegetarian options on the menu. Vegetarian guests may need to inquire with the staff for suitable dishes.
Customers often describe Tony's Di Napoli as busy and vibrant, which accompanies a certain level of noise. This environment is generally considered part of the restaurant's charm, though it may not be ideal for patrons seeking a quiet dining experience.
Bustling eatery serving large, shareable portions of Italian comfort food in a lively setting.
