The most frequent themes include significant disappointment with product condition and packaging, which is repeatedly described as damaged or inadequate. Customers across different locations express frustration with the lack of quality control, misrepresentation of item condition (notably “open box” items that appear heavily used), and slow or confusing communication when problems arise. Easy returns are noted in a few instances, but most feedback revolves around product and process dissatisfaction.
In summary, GoodBuy Gear is regarded by reviewers as a convenient concept for purchasing secondhand baby gear but faces major reputation challenges due to inconsistent quality and customer support, especially around returns and transparency. These themes dominate customer perceptions and negatively influence trust in the company’s operations.