Major positive themes include the simplicity of gifting and the environmental benefits of digital cards. Customers value being able to schedule delivery and choose between email or text for sending. Conversely, critical feedback is dominated by complaints about double charges, gifts not being received or accepted, lack of live customer support, and challenges with order refunds. Several users raised concerns about the legitimacy of the service following unresolved issues.
Overall, GiftYa maintains a reputation for user-friendly digital gifting but faces repeated criticism for customer support and reliability. The company is recognized for its convenience but must address payment processing and resolution processes to build greater trust with its user base.