Recurrent themes across feedback include frustration with EverBank’s online systems and account verification processes, conflicting verbal and written policies, and slow or inadequate responses to security problems. Some negative feedback centers on access to funds, unauthorized account holds, and unreimbursed ATM errors. On the positive side, a minority of reviewers consistently appreciate the branch-level interaction, noting polite greetings, prompt help, and specific staff by name for their professionalism.
Overall, EverBank is regarded as an institution with considerable inconsistency in service delivery, especially as experienced by customers both in-person and online. While a subset of clients in local branches express ongoing loyalty due to personable staff and efficient transactions, broader feedback—especially from digital banking and account management—suggests ongoing operational and communication challenges. Reputation appears to vary significantly depending on the channel and location of service.