AI-powered Google Reviews Widget - FREE
Free Google reviews widget for your website
Increase sales, trust and credibility with ai.
Mike, Adam and another 21,516 have joined the waitlist.

Calogero's Reviews

Rated 4.5 based on 337 Reviews

919 Franklin Ave, Garden City, NY 11530, United States

Italian Restaurants Garden City

Published on
July 6, 2025
Last updated
July 6, 2025

Reviews Summary

Customer feedback for Calogero’s restaurant is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers consistently noting the excellent service, accommodating staff, and high-quality food. Guests mention that the team went out of their way to meet last-minute needs, celebrate special occasions, and offer thoughtful touches like congratulatory desserts. There are occasional criticisms, such as a dish needing reheating and some comments on price, but these are infrequent and minor compared to the overall praise.

Key reputation themes include friendly and attentive service, flexibility for events, and consistent food quality across both casual gatherings and special celebrations. Many reviewers mention returning regularly for lunch or hosting events, underscoring a loyal customer base. The ambiance, attention to cleanliness, and clear communication from staff also emerge as valued aspects, with several diners acknowledging the restaurant’s efforts to create a welcoming environment for both small and large parties.

Overall, Calogero’s enjoys a strong reputation as a reliable Italian restaurant in its community, known for hosting memorable events and maintaining high standards in both food and service. Customers appreciate its accommodating approach and detail-oriented staff, making it a go-to spot for locals seeking both everyday and special-occasion dining.

Read more

What Customers Are Saying About Calogero's?

extremely happy with the food

spectacular job

very friendly, good food and quick service

incredibly friendly

Service was very attentive

very accommodating

fantastic choice

very hygienic (cleaned/sanitized)

Food was delicious

Friendly service

Trustguide extracts key phrases from reviews about Calogero's and sort them by sentiment. This gives you a quick view of what customers consistently praise or raise concerns about—without needing to read every review.

Satisfaction Score

Based on the set of reviews used to generate this report, it appears that 90% of Calogero's's customers had a positive experience.

Positive
90%
Neutral
0%
Negative
10%

Calogero's Ratings

5

As of Based on 337 revies as of Jul 06, 2025

Calogero's Score

90%

As of Based on 337 revies as of Jul 06, 2025

Got a busrning question about Calogero's?

Claim your profile. Tell the world about your key services, industry customers, or other valuable information.

Customer Reviews

As of Jul 06, 2025, 337 customers have reviewed this business and rated it 4.5 Star out of 5. Trustguide conducted an in-depth analysis of Calogero's's publicly available reviews View source

Cristina Da Cruz rated Calogero's 5 stars
3 years ago
I must say I was extremely happy with the food and service that was provided at my daughter's baby sprinkle. It was a last minute event as she lives out of state. They were all accommodating with the menu, décor and even opened the restaurant earlier so that all the decorators were able to take their time and make it look beautiful. I am so happy I was able to hold the event here and would recommend it to anyone looking to have a party.
Dennis M. rated Calogero's 5 stars
a year ago
Thought they all did a spectacular job. Our waiters explanation of all the dishes was important to us. Our waiter knew the menu and spoke off of it with great enthusiasm. This is a very important thing to keep people coming back. It was my wife's birthday (who is a great cook) and I love to grill as well. My Wife ordered the seafood with spaghetti and I finished it . We thought it was well prepared. Prices were fine food was great and the service spectacular. Packed for a Thursday night. Make reservations.
Jan Hrivnak rated Calogero's 5 stars
a year ago
Staying in a nearby hotel, and evening being since and warm, made me feel like I wanted to walk a bit to find something healthy, delicious but also not overpriced to eat. Google reviews is what I normally use and Calogero’s caught my eye as they had pretty high score already and were open until 10pm. It was already past 8:15pm so I decided to give it a try. Nice people, very friendly, good food and quick service made me feel they deserve 5 stars. If you are looking for an extraordinary experience, this is not the place but it hits all points when it comes to good food in a cozy atmosphere.

Frequently Asked Questions About Calogero's

Can Calogero’s host private events or parties?

Yes, Calogero’s frequently accommodates special occasions such as showers, birthdays, and graduations. Reviews indicate that the staff is flexible with event scheduling, menu customization, and setup, including early restaurant access for decorators.

Is the staff at Calogero’s attentive and friendly?

Multiple reviews praise the staff for being friendly, accommodating, and attentive to guest needs. Special touches like personalized desserts and helpful explanations of menu items are commonly mentioned.

Are there options for outdoor dining at Calogero’s?

Yes, Calogero’s offers outdoor dining, as noted by guests who plan to return to lunch outdoors in the fall and mention of a decorated outside tent for events.

About Calogero's

Italian Restaurants
Calogero’s is a full-service Italian restaurant that provides dine-in meals, special event hosting, and private dining experiences. The restaurant offers a diverse menu with classic Italian dishes, drinks, and desserts, catering both to casual diners and customers celebrating milestones such as showers, graduations, and birthdays.

The company operates through in-person service, employing attentive staff who assist with everything from meal selection to event coordination. Flexible scheduling, private event spaces, and customer-oriented practices, such as accommodating special requests or dietary needs, are core to its workflow. Attention to cleanliness and detailed preparation are regularly observed.
Expand

How is this report generated

Trustguide generates concise, neutral summaries of business reviews. By analyzing publicly available feedback from reputable platforms, it highlights common experiences, praises, and concerns. This allows users to quickly understand a business’s reputation without reading every individual review.4o
Own this business? email us at hello@trustguide.ai.
7346397840918440291

How was your experience with Calogero's?

People also checked

Sorellina logo
Sorellina

Rated 4 stars

Amalia - Italian Restaurant Liverpool logo
Amalia

Rated 4 stars

Amarone logo
Amarone

Rated 5 stars

Gusto Italian logo
Gusto Italian

Rated 4 stars

Don Giovanni - Italian Restaurant Manchester logo
Don Giovanni

Rated 5 stars

Cucina Rustica logo
Cucina Rustica

Rated 4 stars

Casa Italia logo
Casa Italia

Rated 4 stars

Show your best reviews to your future customers
95% of your customers read online reviews. Make it easy for them.
Mike, Adam and another 21,516 have joined the waitlist.