AI-powered Google Reviews Widget - FREE
Free Google reviews widget for your website
Increase sales, trust and credibility with ai.
Mike, Adam and another 21,516 have joined the waitlist.
ButcherBox logo

ButcherBox Reviews

Rated 4.3 based on 2713 Reviews

311 Arsenal St, Watertown, MA 02472, United States

Online Stores Watertown

Published on
July 24, 2025
Last updated
July 24, 2025

Reviews Summary

ButcherBox receives mixed feedback from customers regarding its meat subscription service. Reviewers consistently note strengths in meat variety, the potential for high meat quality, and the attentive support provided by some staff members, like Hailey and James. However, significant concerns are also raised about delivery delays, poor communication, billing issues, and variable meat quality. Some customers recall excellent experiences initially, but mention a notable decline in product consistency over time.

The most frequent positive themes among ButcherBox reviewers involve the convenience of home delivery, clear sourcing practices with non-GMO and ethically raised meats, and well-packaged shipments arriving promptly when operations run smoothly. Negative themes include reports of spoiled or poor-quality meats, dissatisfaction with customer service—particularly regarding unresolved refunds or difficulties canceling—and worries about inadequate quality control in shipping.

Overall, ButcherBox is viewed as a convenient solution for obtaining meat products, especially for those who value transparent sourcing or have dietary preferences. However, in regions ranging from Texas to California, inconsistent product quality and unresolved customer service experiences temper its reputation. Repeat business is common, but is jeopardized by failures in reliability and issue resolution.
Read more

What Customers Are Saying About ButcherBox?

She was very helpful

quality meat for the price 👌

The quality of the meat is fantastic

prompt, and I appreciate that they use recyclable materials

excellent in taste and quality

order arrived quickly and well-packaged

excellent quality beef, pork, chicken, and seafood

delivered efficiently and still frozen

exceptional quality of the meat

the convenience of having everything delivered

Trustguide extracts key phrases from reviews about ButcherBox and sort them by sentiment. This gives you a quick view of what customers consistently praise or raise concerns about—without needing to read every review.

Satisfaction Score

Based on the set of reviews used to generate this report, it appears that 40% of ButcherBox's customers had a positive experience.

Positive
40%
Neutral
10%
Negative
50%

ButcherBox Ratings

1

As of Based on 2713 revies as of Jul 24, 2025

ButcherBox Score

40%

As of Based on 2713 revies as of Jul 24, 2025

Got a busrning question about ButcherBox?

Claim your profile. Tell the world about your key services, industry customers, or other valuable information.

Customer Reviews

As of Jul 24, 2025, 2713 customers have reviewed this business and rated it 4.3 Star out of 5. Trustguide conducted an in-depth analysis of ButcherBox's publicly available reviews View source

Kelly Farrak rated ButcherBox 5 stars
Edited 4 months ago
This company has earned its reputation, … I heard about this company first from a YouTube contest creator, on his channel, Universal Mastery, (sorry, Jeremiah, I forgot to use your link so you'd get credit) I checked out their website first, and saw that they specialized in pasture raised animals and the use of Non GMO feed was a feature I most loved. They had a nice variety of meats, lots of specials and member deals..etc. so, I contacted them on around, Feb 3rd, where I communicated with Hailey ,customer sales team. She was very helpful with any concerns I had and was hesitant about. She stayed involved with me until I finally was successful in placing my order. First couple of times failed due to some unexpected technical issues. So, once placing my subscription for the custom box, where you pick all your own favorite items, which you can change up whenever you want. Got my confirmation email shortly after. It gives you a window of your estimated arrival. Mine was ordered on the 3rd of February..the estimated delivery date was between the 5th and 8th same month. So happily I waited only to not get any further training or update. So I emailed Hailey again, she apologized, but said that the order hadn't been delivered yet but was packed. I also received an email showing the tracking status where the order was still in the "boxing" status on the 6th. Here's where things soured a bit for me. On the 8th, I reached out again, because according to them, I was estimated to be receiving my box no later than the 8th. Hailey email me back with a order run down and normal schedule time. I replied politely, thanks for the update, and was glad this isn't your typical way of doing things. On the 10th, Hailey emailed me back with this... "I'm so sorry for the inconvenience caused. I've confirmed with our fulfillment center that your order has been processed for shipping and you should receive your tracking shortly. When your box ships, you’ll receive an email notification from support, with tracking information, letting you know your order is on the way." So by now, I was beginning to think about this, I already had to make do, by substituting store bought meat, while the wait for my delivery, and it looked like Hailey didn't really have a answer. I thought that I'd better cancel this and get my money back..but when I went to the website..couldn't find anywhere where this action is done. So, I called the support number, which, BTW, is always a good sign that a company offers live agents to help you..I reached agent named James, ultra professional and very knowledgeable...kind too. He heard the whole spiel on what happened. I actually was calling to find out how to cancel! He said that once your order was already packed or "boxed"..you could cancel the future order, but for this one, you can not get a refund. I certainly didn't like that, because my order was in the packed status ..too long. James looked up my order, and told me that my order had indeed been ready for pickup, but for some reason their shipping courier was having a problem, hence the unordinary delay. Hailey should have relayed this to me. But he said after a short hold, I'm being shipped promptly out that evening He also compensated me for the problems. I accepted humbly, due to his diligence and genuine concern for my "new customer experience". He explained that they can deliver once shipped in 3 days, because they have several local warehouses throughout the cities, which is also great to know. So, I received my package the next day..and everything was perfectly packed, frozen. Lots of meat, quality meat for the price 👌 I had my first ribeye,..... tender, juicy and, although I've been a devoted vegetarian since 2018 I instantly returned back, to the last time I had a real prime steak. The flavor is unmistakable. Meat lovers know what I'm talking about. So, due to being anemic, doctors recommend that I get some meat in me..I don't believe that if I had to (cut off)
Jake Richards rated ButcherBox 4 stars
4 months ago
I am leaving 4 stars because we have received many good box’s from this company. While I hate to leave a “bad review” I won’t leave them a 1 star. Butcher box started out great. The meat looked good, and tasted great. Very tender meat and all was well…for the first 6 months. Then it was like an entirely different company took over (or it’s a bait and switch) For the second half of the year all we got was either brown, mangled, oddly shaped meat. If it wasn’t brown or mangled it was absolutely riddled with silver skin. Too chewy to eat. We really gave it a shot, thought maybe it was a bad box. We waited for 6 months! 6 box’s and it only got worse and worse. We eventually cancelled our membership. Also just to mention these were all prime cuts (ribeye, ny strip, filet). Below is a NY strip that is mangled and has silver skin running all the way through the middle of the entire steak..
Abby Mann rated ButcherBox 1 stars
4 months ago
Poor customer service. I have been considering canceling my account as I haven't been impressed with the portions compared to value in my past two orders. I was checking my bank account and noticed a charge from ButcherBox. I did not recall setting up an order. Usually there is also a heads up notification email that would prompt me to adjust my order. I did not receive it and if I had would have cancelled the order. Immediately I logged into my account and the order said processing. I reach out on chat to ask that the box be canceled and got an auto response that customer service did not open until 8 am and someone would email me. A few hours later I reach out as I no one contacted me. I asked for the order to be cancelled and issue a refund. The customer service agent told me my order had been processed and could not be canceled. If my order had been processed then the person should have been able to tell me the tracking number and what was in my box. She could not provide any of this information. She also implied that I did not know how to access email in my Gmail. As I would not be able to retrieve the box and the food would go to waste I requested a partial refund. It was also suggested I reach out to a shelter who could use the food. While it is a nice gesture, I don't have $146 to expend for that. Instead I was told they could offer a $73 replacement box which would me I would end up paying $219. I asked for a contact to a manager and was told someone would email me. Incredibly dissatisfied is an understatement. Update: I sent email as instructed. As of 6/28/2025 no one has responded an I have not received my refund.

Frequently Asked Questions About ButcherBox

What type of meat quality can I expect from ButcherBox?

Customers report variable experiences: some consistently receive high-quality, well-packaged meats, while others have experienced issues such as brown or tough cuts and occasional spoilage. Quality may fluctuate over time or between shipments.

How reliable is ButcherBox's shipping and delivery?

Shipping is typically prompt and packaging maintains freshness. However, there are multiple reports of delivery delays or damaged boxes. Some customers experienced issues with transit times, with a few orders arriving spoiled. Best results occur when operations run smoothly.

How are subscription modifications, cancellations, or refunds handled?

Cancelling or modifying orders can be difficult once processing begins. Some customers had trouble receiving refunds or timely support responses. Live support is available, but resolutions and refund offers can vary depending on the situation.

About ButcherBox

Online Stores
ButcherBox provides a subscription-based meat delivery service, offering a range of products including beef, pork, chicken, turkey, seafood, and bison. The company emphasizes sourcing practices such as grass-fed beef and humanely raised meats, operating primarily through online ordering and home delivery across the United States.

Orders are processed via their website, with customers selecting box sizes and cuts according to their preferences. Shipments are packaged for freshness and delivered directly to subscribers' homes. ButcherBox manages logistics using regional warehouses and third-party couriers, aiming to ensure timely and properly preserved deliveries.
Expand

How is this report generated

Trustguide generates concise, neutral summaries of business reviews. By analyzing publicly available feedback from reputable platforms, it highlights common experiences, praises, and concerns. This allows users to quickly understand a business’s reputation without reading every individual review.4o
Own this business? email us at hello@trustguide.ai.
8064685721785973037

How was your experience with ButcherBox?

People also checked

Ulta Beauty logo
Ulta Beauty

Rated 5 stars

GoodBuy Gear Denver logo
GoodBuy Gear Denver

Rated 1 stars

ItsWorthMore logo
ItsWorthMore

Rated 5 stars

Lifecell Skin Care logo
Lifecell Skin Care

Rated 5 stars

Nutstop logo
Nutstop

Rated 5 stars

Shiny Smile Veneers logo
Shiny Smile Veneers

Rated 5 stars

Show your best reviews to your future customers
95% of your customers read online reviews. Make it easy for them.
Mike, Adam and another 21,516 have joined the waitlist.