The most frequent themes in the reviews are the delicious range of sweet and savoury waffles, the accommodating and friendly staff, and the picturesque outdoor seating area. Patrons mention that the queue management system, which does not allow pre-booking, can be inconvenient—especially for elderly or disabled guests. Portions have also been noted by repeat customers to have reduced over time.
Overall, The Waffle House in St Albans is regarded as a popular and distinctive café destination, known in the local region for its inclusive menu and inviting atmosphere. Despite operational criticisms, many guests express intent to return and recommend it for casual brunch outings.