The most frequent themes revolve around questionable lead quality, excessive or unexpected charges, and a failure to provide human support. Multiple professionals mention fake or disconnected leads, unresolved billing issues, and feeling forced to pay for “dead” opportunities. There is recurring criticism of Thumbtack’s automated systems, lack of transparency, and punitive actions when professionals attempt to dispute charges. Several reviews mention geographic details such as San Francisco and the Colorado Rockies.
Overall, Thumbtack is perceived as untrustworthy by professionals in the United States, particularly when it comes to supporting businesses and managing payments. Reviewers repeatedly caution others to avoid the service, citing an environment where legitimate support and genuine business leads are hard to come by. The company’s reputation as a reliable partner for professionals appears severely damaged in these reviews.